Lurked for a month. What is the one thing you wish you had been told?
About to place a first trade on a small live account after a long time on demo.
How much macro does a technical trader actually need?
Trying to work out whether this is essential or a different discipline I can safely ignore for now.
US30 or NAS100 to start with?
Assume the answer is neither until I know what I am doing, but if forced to choose.
Complete beginner: should I start with an EA at all?
Everything I read says automation removes emotion, which sounds like exactly what I need. But I also do not understand enough to judge whether an EA is any good.
Is a 2 year old EA outdated?
Looking at something last updated in 2024. Is that old in this context or is that a silly question?
Which rule catches people most often?
Reading through a few rulebooks and trying to work out where the real risk is.
How many brokers did you try before settling?
On my second and wondering whether shopping around further is worth the account opening admin.
What does "optimised" actually mean when a vendor says it?
Seeing it on every product page and I suspect it does not mean anything.
Where do people actually learn MQL5?
The official docs assume you already program. Everything else I find is a paid course.
How much does index dividend adjustment actually cost a short?
Understand the mechanism in theory. Trying to work out whether it is a rounding error or something that matters on a multi-week position.
Is there a point at which you stop journalling?
Doing it religiously and it is starting to feel like admin rather than insight.
How long do you run something live before you trust it?
Three months? Six? A hundred trades? Trying to work out what a reasonable bar is before I size up.
Too early for me to attempt one of these?
Three months in, small live account, roughly break even. Tempted but suspect the answer is obvious.
Earnings gaps: is there any edge in fading them?
Looks tempting on the chart afterwards, which is usually a warning sign.
Does anyone read the execution quality reports brokers publish?
Some publish statistics on fill quality. No idea whether they are comparable between firms or whether each defines the terms differently.
Passed. Sitting on my hands before I start.
Cleared the evaluation on Friday. Every instinct says trade immediately. Taking the week off instead, which feels wrong and is probably right.
How do you define "confirmation" without just waiting until the move is over?
Every confirmation rule I add improves my win rate and destroys my average win. There must be a middle somewhere.
Where do you get your macro reading from without paying for a terminal?
Trying to build a routine that does not cost more than my account is worth.
Single stock CFDs: is anyone bothering?
Spreads look wide compared to the index and the borrow costs on shorts seem punitive. Wondering if I am missing a use case.